Micro Influencers vs. Macro Influencers: Which Delivers Better ROI?

Article Image
Photo Source: PeopleImages/Shutterstock

Compare the return on investment (ROI) of micro and macro influencers and you’ll quickly see micros pulling ahead.  

Disrupt Marketing estimates: 

  • Average influencer marketing ROI between £5 and £6.50 for every £1 spent 
  • Average micro campaign delivering 5x to 8x returns 
  • Average macro campaign delivering 3x to 5x returns  

In other words, macro influencer marketing is good, but micro is often better. Is that the end of the story? No.  

The level of influencer or content creator you choose ultimately depends on the results you’re trying to achieve. Sometimes a micro influencer strategy simply won’t meet those goals like a macro strategy.  

Follower count is important when finding influencers, but there’s plenty more to consider if your campaign is to be successful.  

Let’s dig deeper into those details. 

JUMP TO

What is a micro influencer and what is a macro influencer?

Influencers are often divided into only micro and macro, with follower counts coming in at 10,000 to 100,000 for micro influencers and 100,000 to 1 million for macro influencers.  

But narrower influencer tiers can be useful when you’re considering cost and engagement, so it’s worth laying them out. 

  • Nano: 1,000 to 10,000 followers 
  • Micro: 10,000 to 50,000 followers 
  • Midtier: 50,000 to 500,000 followers 
  • Macro: 500,000 to 1 million followers 
  • Mega: Over 1 million followers 

Cost of hiring a micro vs. macro influencer  

We can’t quote concrete costs. Nobody can. Everything from engagement rate to industry niche skews the cost of hiring an influencer.  

Prices according to Disrupt influencer marketing agency:  

  • Nano: £50 to £250 
  • Micro: £250 to £1,500 
  • Midtier: £1,500 to £5,000 
  • Macro: £5,000 to £20,000 or more 

Costs according to the agency Influencer Matchmaker:  

  • Nano: £100 to £350 
  • Micro: £350 to £1,000 
  • Midtier: £1,000 to £5,000 
  • Macro: £5,000 to £12,000 

“It’s important to note that these figures are not fixed,” writes Disrupt’s Hannah Turner. “Two creators with similar followings can command very different fees depending on engagement quality, content output, exclusivity, and how their content is used by the brand.” 

Engagement rate  

Engagement rate describes the percentage of users who interacted with content rather than simply scrolling past.  

Interactions include:  

  • Likes 
  • Comments 
  • Shares/reposts 
  • Saves 
  • Clicks (on links or to profiles)  
  • DMs 

Add up total interactions, divide by follower size, and multiply by 100 – that’s your engagement rate, and higher is always better.  

Smaller follower counts generally correlate with higher engagement rates, as seen across platform averages from Amplify Influencer. 

Instagram 

  • 1,000 to 10,000 followers: 3.5% to 8% 
  • 10,000 to 100,000 followers: 2.5% to 5% 
  • 100,000 to 1 million followers: 1.5% to 3% 
  • Over 1 million followers: 0.8% to 2% 

TikTok 

  • 1,000 to 10,000 followers: 5% to 12% 
  • 10,000 to 100,000 followers: 4% to 8% 
  • 100,000 to 1 million followers: 3% to 6% 
  • Over 1 million followers: 2% to 4% 

YouTube  

  • 1,000 to 10,000 followers: 2% to 5% 
  • 10,000 to 100,000 followers: 1.5% to 3% 
  • 100,000 to 1 million followers: 1% to 2.5% 
  • Over 1 million followers: 0.5% to 1.5% 

Where micro influencer marketing excels

Engagement 

“Smaller creators naturally have higher engagement levels,” says Stack Influence founder William Gasner. “They have more trust with their audience. It’s a more tight-knit follower base.” Added trust lends weight to recommendations and endorsements.  

Smaller audiences mean creators can respond to every comment and DM, including those about your brand. Tight-knit communities can form groups of loyal customers. As such, micro influencers shine in campaigns focused on interactions or building trust and authenticity. 

Such close relationships with their followers also grants a deep understanding of what resonates, so consider micros a potential gold mine of invaluable insights into your target audience.  

Conversions  

Micro influencers bring 5x to 8x returns when campaigns are well executed. All that trust and engagement comes into its own when conversions are needed.  

Real-world examples bear this out: 

  • Airalo: 10 TikTok micro influencers generated a 12.3% engagement rate and a cost-per-install (CPI) of $0.23 (£0.17) – way below the $1.50 (£1.14) global average.  
  • The Honest Company: 30 micro influencers generated 578 link clicks to their website and 1,402 sticker taps to its Instagram profile. 

Flexibility 

Investing in a wide range of smaller influencers rather than a few larger ones means you’re not putting all your eggs in one basket. Brands can diversify campaigns across multiple platforms and influencers to find what fits or encourage widespread production of user-generated content (UGC).  

Pet food brand I and Love and You did just that by partnering with 400 micro influencers who created 122 posts, reached 7.8 million people, and received 64,000 engagements. 

Authenticity  

Grocery chain Iceland’s move from using celebrity spokespeople to micro influencers provides an example of how such shifts can boost a brand’s reputation.  

Nationally recognised names like Peter Andre and Kerry Katona were dropped. Instead, mums from the YouTube community were approached to promote products in a more “authentic” fashion.  

It worked. Iceland’s approval rate among mums soared from 10% to 80%. 

Niche  

Micro influencers build strong followings in specific niches, and they can vibe particular well with similarly niche brands.  

Wireless fish finder brand Deepersonar is pretty darn niche, and its ambassador program makes excellent use of micro influencers (who make up a huge majority of members).  

Ambassadors must have a genuine need for and interest in the product, an audience mainly geographically located in a target market, and in-depth tutorials or videos of products in action. The ambassadors program is Deepersonar’s top revenue-driving channel. 

Where macro influencer marketing excels

influencer

Credit: PeopleImages/Shutterstock

Reach 

Macros can promote your brand to more people than micros. “With their wide-reaching influence and high-quality content, they have the ability to amplify your brand across multiple platforms,” writes Gretchen Oestreicher for Metricool. This is great for building awareness.  

US-based yoga brand Alo, for example, used influencers to raise its profile, including macros such as Megan Williams and Georgia Mae Gibbs. As reported by TheIndustry.fashion, “this squad of devoted supporters hyped new collections and reliably included Alo Yoga pieces in everyday style and fitness content, helping #AloPartner garner $772,000 (£581,000) EMV [earned media value, the estimated equivalent of brand awareness].”  

Speed 

Macros can introduce a brand to hundreds of thousands of people in a single post, video, or stream, so they’re particularly effective at creating strong impressions quickly. That is ultra handy for: 

  • Catching trends 
  • New product launches 
  • Limited offers 
  • Seasonal campaigns 
  • Major announcements 

Nike and L’Oréal routinely take advantage by partnering with macro influencers for major product launches, but even smaller names can profit.  

HDMI Licensing Administrator (HDMI LA) effectively promoted its 2022 HDMI 2.1a Specification by partnering with three macro Twitch streamers: IFrostbolt (352,000) followers, Tru3Ta1ent (685,000) followers, and ZKMushroom (190,000) followers. 

Streams gained over 159,000 hours of total watch time and saw HDMI LA site views increase from 139 in October to 827 in December.  

Production value 

Macro influencers generally possess the experience and resources necessary for high-quality content able to positively reflect your brand.  

But highly polished content isn’t always optimal. The authenticity and relatability associated with less “produced” content is often a better fit.  

On the other hand, higher production value may appeal to brands that have specific style standards they like to maintain across all platforms or that are interested in paying extra for the right to repurpose an influencer’s content for use in further marketing.  

Authority  

Larger audiences bring industrywide respect, endowing macro influencers and their endorsements with weighty authority.  

“Having a recognized name endorse your product signals legitimacy to a wider market,” writes Influee’s Katja Orel. “This is valuable for brands entering new categories, launching in new markets, or running PR-style campaigns where visibility matters more than direct conversions.”  

That’s probably why Lululemon partnered with Dr Hazel Wallace, a former NHS medical doctor, registered associate nutritionist, and personal trainer with tons of credibility (plus 795,000 Instagram followers at the time). 

“The collaboration with Dr Wallace increased the brand’s credibility and relevance in a key demographic,” according to Kolsquare. 

Broad audiences  

Whereas micro influencers excel within niche communities, macro influencers bring broad appeal across diverse audiences. That can be useful for products that also have a wide appeal across diverse audiences.  

Take Häagen-Dazs’ partnership with singer-songwriter Leslie Grace (then 233,000 followers strong on TikTok) in a campaign that generated over 20 million TikTok impressions. She had nothing to do with ice cream, but why does that matter when ice cream has such wide appeal? 

How to Measure the ROI of micro and macro influencers

You can’t determine ROI without specifying the expected return. Is it getting the most eyes on your product or earning the most sales? Is it increasing your own audience or strengthening ties in existing communities? 

Here are a few key KPIs.  

Awareness 

Let’s say you’re a clothing brand hoping to create visibility for a new collection. You might look at: 

  • Reach: How many people see an influencer’s content 
  • Impressions: Number of times content is displayed (including repeats) 
  • Video completion rate (VCR): Percentage of viewers who watched videos to the end 
  • Total website traffic: Measure overall visitors before, during, and after your campaign 
  • New website visitors: Track first-time visitors to your site 
  • Cost per mille (CPM): Campaign cost divided by total impressions, multiplied by 1,000 
  • Earned media value (EMV): Multiply total impressions by CPM 

Conversions  

Now suppose your hypothetical clothing brand wants a boost in sales for particular products. Relevant KPIs would include:  

  • Conversion rate (CVR): Percentage of link clicks that went on to complete the intended action (such as a purchase) 
  • Customer acquisition cost (CAC): Cost of campaign divided by number of new customers acquired 
  • Sales: Through affiliate links and promotions 
  • Code uses: Special discount codes that identify which customers came from a certain influencer 

Engagement 

To increase the number of people discussing your clothing brand or promoting it among niche communities, you may consider:  

  • Total interactions: Including likes, shares, saves, and comments 
  • Click-through rate (CTR): Percentage of people who saw content and clicked the intended link 
  • Engagement rate (ER): Total engagements divided by total followers, multiplied by 100 
  • Cost per engagement (CPE): Total campaign cost divided by total number of interactions 

Audience growth  

Imagine you’d rather up your clothing brand’s own social media game. Key metrics would include:  

  • Follower count: Number of followers gained during the campaign compared with normal growth rate 
  • Growth rate: Divide the number of new followers by total followers, then multiply by 100